Prevent Duplicate User accounts

Prevent Duplicate User accounts

I am looking to avoid duplicate accounts by adding 01, 02, 03 etc to newly created format. Example, Steve Rosalbo = srosal and if another srosal exists add 02 or 03 etc.
I keep getting error that user account exits after filling in the Prevent Duplicate fields.
                New to ADManager Plus?

                  New to ADSelfService Plus?